Trek Talk Tuesday #3: The Bare Bones


It's time for another Trek Talk!

I said last time I was going to talk about the real McCoy himself, so here we go.

Dr. McCoy is one the best parts of TOS for me. Especially because he reminds so much of another medical professional on a different show - Doc Adams of the Western TV classic Gunsmoke. Both doctors are warm-hearted grouches who try not to show their real natures and offer blunt and timely advice to the main character (Captain Kirk/ Marshall Dillion) while exchanging sharp banter with another character (Spock/ Chester and later Festus). Bones is probably my favorite character in the entirety of Trek, with Scotty making a close second. And there are a few reasons for that.

First, Bones is like a link to the viewer because he doesn't have the same polished nature of so many in Star Trek. While Spock has logic and Kirk has passion, McCoy has common sense - an important necessity for any space voyage.

Second, McCoy is well cast. DeForest Kelly actually was from Georgia, and while I'm assuming the Georgia origin for Bones probably came with hiring Kelly, the idea was smart and adds a convincingness to the character. His southern roots also flow into the understated gentlemanly side of his character.

Third, I would argue he has the best sense of humor.

The greatness that is McCoy makes the medical character of TNG, Beverley Crusher, that much duller, but I'm not gonna rant about TNG today.

What are your thoughts on Dr. McCoy? Let me know in the comments!

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Trek Talk Tuesday #5: Space Elves (Part 1)

Image
Intro A pointy-eared stoic race with a dedication to logic and reason - these are the Vulcans. Gene Rodenberry's Space Elves are easily the most iconic alien race of the Star Trek  universe thanks to Mr. Spock. Other Vulcan characters of note include Surak, Sarek, Tuvok, and T'Pol. I have not seen Voyager  aside from a few episodes so I have no opinion of Tuvok but T'Pol is probably the least enjoyable Vulcan of the bunch. She conveys less the idea of logic and more a sense of resentment for being stuck with humans. Vulcans have always struck me as quite inconsistent as despite their professed adherence to logic they are nonetheless deeply mystical. The Enterprise  episode "The Andorian Incident" features a Vulcan Monastery, for example, and of course, we have the classic TOS episode "Amok Time" in which we learn just how violent the Vulcan mating ritual is. Granted, this is seen as logical, a releasing of emotions for an intense but short per
Read more

Review: Avengers - Infinity War (SPOILERS)

Image
I'm not a fan of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, but this week I decided to give "Infinity War" a go. I have seen a handful of MCU movies before, so I was not lost in terms of the overall plot at any point I knew who most of the characters were. For reference, the Marvel Films I've seen prior to this are: "Thor", "Antman", "Dr. Strange", both of the "Guardians of the Galaxy" movies and "Civil War."  Of those I loved Antman and enjoyed the Guardians (which are more Space Western Adventures than Superhero movies, which is why I liked them) and thought Thor was fine aside from the shallow nature of Jane's attraction to Thor. My review then is from the perspective of someone who is familiar with the franchise but not a fan. I say this because otherwise I'm worried perceived opinions on IW will come down to "well, fans loved it but non-fans were confused and didn't like it." I'm not a fan,
Read more

Trek Talk Tuesday #1 : Series Intro

Image
To keep a semblance of a regular schedule and because I've been getting back into Star Trek  following the announcement of Sir Patrick Stewart's return as Captain Picard, I'm planning a new series for this blog called "Trek Talk Tuesday". Lord willing I will post something every Tuesday but life makes such promises fragile. Suffice to say I will do my best to post one of these every Tuesday. I am of course more into Star Wars , Tolkien's Middle-earth and  Battlestar Galactica (1978) then I am into Star Trek  but I do enjoy it and in my own way, I love it. But don't expect me to be the fountain of nerd-knowledge here. Since this is my first post on Star Trek , I think a good place to start is establishing what parts I've seen and my overall feelings about the enterprise (pun intended). And in the coming weeks, I will look more in depth at some of the topics I will raise here. I have seen all of The Original Series (TOS), at least I think I have
Read more